Life Line June 9, 2004 Volume 1: Issue 3


Dear Reader:

We hope that last month's article on Mel Gibson's movie "The Passion of the Christ" generated lively discussions. It was interesting to hear from those who were on both sides of this controversial yet highly important piece of filmmaking. It is our goal to continue to offer editorial commentary on some of today's hot button issues. Please know that your suggestions are always welcome and we encourage you to continue to send us your questions.  We welcome your feedback, which can be e-mailed to us at info@light-n-life.com. If you would like to be removed from our mailing list please click here or click the unsubscribe button below.

Sincerely in Christ,
The Staff at Light & Life Publishing


 

       Any discussion about this topic must necessarily be predicated on the Orthodox understanding of homosexuality, on the one hand, and Holy Matrimony, on the other.  After grasping the Church's position on these, one can affirm the statement issued by the Standing Conference of the Canonical Orthodox Bishops in the Americas (SCOBA) on Aug. 27, 2003 entitled "On the Moral Crisis in our Nation": 

"The Orthodox Christian teaching on marriage and sexuality, firmly grounded in Holy Scripture, 2000 years of church tradition, and canon law, holds that marriage consists in the conjugal union of a man and a woman, and that authentic marriage is blessed by God as a sacrament of the Church.  Neither Scripture nor Holy Tradition blesses or sanctions such a union between persons of the same sex."
       Orthodoxy teaches that, while homosexual orientation is not a sin, like adultery and fornication, homosexual acts are.  In Romans 1:24-27 St. Paul talks about men committing "indecent acts with other men" and receiving the "due penalty for their perversion."  In his first letter to the people of Corinth Paul includes "homosexual offenders" in the list of those who will not "inherit the kingdom of God" (I Cor. 6:9-10).  In Genesis we read the story of Sodom and Gomorrah whose sin of homosexual activity is "exceedingly grave" (Gen. 18:20; 19:4-5).  And in Leviticus God tells Moses to instruct the Israelites: "Do not lie with a man as one lies with a woman; it is an abomination" (18:22).
       Some modern apologists for homosexuality say that those prohibitions have no validity since some recent studies contend that people are born with a homosexual orientation, rather than choosing it, a theory not espoused in earlier times.  Although there is presently no conclusive evidence to support this contention, even if the theory of genetically determined sexual orientation were ultimately proven true, the position of Orthodoxy would not change.  Human beings, although created in God's image, have, since the fall, been predisposed to sin.  A person might be predisposed towards violence, anger, pedophilia, lying, adultery, or countless other sinful urges, and yet still chooses whether or not to act on them.  Saying sin is "natural" is no argument before God.  He desires that we repent of whatever evil tendency might grip us, in our fallen state, and be saved.  But Orthodoxy, especially, remembers that we have a loving and merciful God to help us on our road to recovery and union (theosis) with Him. 
       In the first book of the Bible we learn that God created man and woman to help and complement each other.  Created in God's image, male and female, Adam and Eve were entrusted with caring for the rest of God's creation (Gen. 1:27-29).  The unique relationship of man and woman is more clearly delineated by the second creation narrative in chapter two of Genesis.  In this version God created the animals to be a "suitable helper" for Adam, but none among the animals was found suitable for this unique role.  It was only when God created Eve that Adam felt completed and compatible with her.  The proclamation at the end of this section has become the theological underpinning of Holy Matrimony: "For this reason a man will leave his father and mother and be united to his wife, and they will become one flesh" (Gen. 2:24).
       The Mystery of Holy Matrimony reflects this sacred union effected by God Himself.  Every aspect of the Orthodox theology of marriage involves this action by God to unite the man and woman.  That is why the Orthodox understanding of marriage espouses three purposes for marriage described theologically by the Greek words: synousia, paidhopoiea, and syzygia
       Syzygia denotes the male and female being "yoked together."  In Christian marriage the man and woman are intimately joined on a common journey leading to salvation.  They are headed the same direction, side by side, in a complementary fashion.  God has brought them together and bound them to each other in a mystical communion ordained by God Himself.
      Paidhopoiea literally means to "create a child" and denotes the procreative aspect of marriage.  In a wider sense it can also mean to rear a child.  Even though every marriage does not entail having or rearing children, ideally marriage allows a man and woman to have a conjugal union that leads to procreation; that mystical act where God allows us to participate in creation with Him.
      Synousia is a compound word which means the "coming together of two natures."  Interestingly it is the proper Greek word for sexual intercourse within marriage.  Within the union of Holy Matrimony sexual relationships between husband and wife are more than just procreative, they also are the mystical expression of the two natures "becoming one" in the context of marital love.
      Homosexual relationships, by their nature, lack God's mystical efficacy and can never produce the oneness that God desires for Christian marriage.  In the Orthodox understanding "Gay marriage" misses the mark of synousia, syzygia, and paidhopoiea, and is therefore an inauthentic expression of God's unifying love.


Toward a Eucharistic Vision of Church, Family, Marriage and Sex
by Philip LeMasters, Ph.D.

Recommended by: 
Anthony M. Coniaris


       By its very essence Orthodox Christian life is "eucharistic." We consume the Body of Christ in the sacrament in order to become the Body of Christ, the Church. "Holy Communion" – understood in the broader sense of celebration as well as consummation – is the most fundamental and significant action we can perform. On it are based, without exception, all other aspects of Christian life and activity.
       Fr. John Breck says of this book, "The thrust of this book, and its value for Orthodox Christians, especially in the West today, is well expressed by a statement toward its close, ‘Orthodox moral theology remains Eucharistic and pastoral, focused on bringing fallen human beings into fuller communion with the Holy Trinity.' The emphasis, reinforced by hundreds of lengthy quotations from patristic and modern theologians contained chiefly in the notes, makes of this a work to be read and studied in Parish groups as well as by married couples. It speaks directly and forcefully to a major crisis within the Church as well as within society, and provides a perspective for which we can only express our own eucharistia."
       The author examines the Eucharist in the many ways it affects our relationship to the Church, the world, marriage, sex, same-sex unions, moral theology, penitential discipline etc.


Marriage: An Orthodox Perspective
by John Meyendorf

Recommended by:
Marianna Priest


       If you'd like to know everything there is to know about the Orthodox view of marriage, this is the book for you.  Fr. John Meyendorf, former dean of St. Vladimir's Seminary, gives us a scholarly yet accessible report on the Biblical and canonical roots of Orthodox beliefs about marriage.
       Fr. Meyendorf tempers the Orthodox doctrine with just a hint toward flexibility, the possibility of which seems to be built into the Orthodox perspective.  Wisdom and "economia" are called forth by the recognized need of compassion for individual human needs and life circumstances. 
       Quoting Fr. Meyendorf,  "Christian marriage consists in transforming and transfiguring a natural human affection between a man and a woman into an eternal bond of love. (p.69)  ...the possibility and the responsibility given to both husband and wife to transfigure their "agreement" into the reality of the Kingdom. (p.18)  Marriage is a sacrament because in it and through it the Kingdom of God beomes a living experience." (p.73)  
       With compassion and doctrinal certainty, Fr. Mayendorf addresses pressing issues such as divorce ("when a first union was a mistake," p.44),  successive marriages, birth control, abortion, celibacy and married clergy.  He speaks eloquently to the fundamental connection between marriage and the Eucharist.    Marriage, An Orthodox Perspective  offers us  comprehensive insight into the meaning of Orthodox marriage.

Copyright © 2004 Light & Life Publishing. All rights reserved. No part of these articles may be reproduced by any means electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise without written permission of Light & Life Publishing.


Dear Light & life,

       What are the rules for remarriage in the Church?  After 28 years, my husband left me for another woman.  Six weeks after our divorce, he was married by a Minister (Church affiliation unknown, but not Orthodox) on a beach.  He now wants to be married in the Church.  What rules apply should I wish to remarry?


       The occurrence of a divorce is one of the most challenging events that a person, couple, family, and even friends can go through.  The particular events revealed in the question above are so painful, and it is the Church's responsibility, in a balanced manner, to help those going through it.  The answer is not so much in "rules applied," as it is in a pastoral care and concern afforded.  Without a doubt, there is a natural tendency to care first for the woman asking the question, especially seeing the apparently profound unfairness of her ex-husband's actions.  The care afforded must have the goal of helping her deal with her pain, anger, resentment, and loss and bring her to a place of forgiveness, and thus, spiritual health.  This is what the Church is about.  The profound theological position of the Mother of God, the Theotokos, reminds us of the nurturing, caring and compassionate Divine Attributes of God.  The Church as the "Mother Church" further expresses these attributes in her care for her members.
       It is within this caring context that the Church deals with divorce.  Of course, the ideal is for a couple to be together their entire life as supported scripturally, historically and naturally.  However, when a divorce does occur, the Church, in great pain and sadness, recognizes that a sacrament has been broken.  She recognizes the frailty of the human condition and our tendency to sin – or "miss the mark".  She then affords the husband or wife an opportunity for repentance – acknowledging this sadness and their responsibility in it, and affording them an opportunity for reconciliation with the Church and even re-marriage within the Church.
       How does re-marriage occur?  The process varies from one Orthodox jurisdiction to the next, but always entails obtaining an ecclesiastical divorce and permission to re-marry.  In some jurisdictions the petitioner appears before an ecclesiastical court for this purpose.  If the petition is granted, the person is free to re-marry a baptized Christian within the church.  In all jurisdictions, however, the local bishop has the authority to grant up to three marriages within the Church for people widowed or divorced.
       Technically, a second or third marriage within the Church is different than a first.  It is of a penitential nature and is not done with the same prayers and celebratory nature as a first marriage.  This may or may not occur in a local parish for a variety of reasons, not the least of which is that oftentimes at least one of the couple is being married for the first time in the Church.  In this case a "first marriage ceremony" likely would be performed.  The first step for re-marriage is to approach your local parish priest who will direct you in the process in your jurisdiction.  Even if your ex-husband negotiates the process to be remarried successfully, you must also go through it so that you are free to re-marry.

 

Send us a question at:
Light & Life Publishing
c/o Questions & Answers
4808 Park Glen Road
Minneapolis, MN. 55416
info@light-n-life.com